home  -  help  -  resources
Introduction Group Brainstorm Share and Sort Assign Points Draft Your Plan

Assign Points
step1 Back to Your Research Groups
Main idea of this step:
Go back with your research group colleagues and decide together what you all think are the most important conservation initiatives on the table. You will have 100 points to assign to the ideas that you favor most.

© WCS

Assign someone to lead this process. That person's job will be to canvass the group and find out how to allocate 100 points to big-ideas or themes that emerged in the previous step.

The leader should go through the different elements-between 6 and 10--of the plan and suggest points. The group should approve that allocation of points or argue for more or less.

The goal is to consider all the needs of jaguars and make well-reasoned decisions based on both your general and specific knowledge. This is the real world of conservation, in which resources -- such as people, money, information -- are limited.

The secret to reaching consensus is to focus on the things everyone agrees about first. After you've built that foundation, deal with issues where there is less agreement.

If you believe strongly in something, work hard to get it accepted; but also keep the larger picture in mind.

step2 Explain Your Decisions
Main idea of this step:
Teams go back to the full workshop and report how their points are allocated and why.
Start by nominating someone to keep a tally of how points are distributed as the teams make their presentations. After the last presentation, that person should assess the number of points received by each action.


step2 Discuss
Staying in your full-class forum, assess the point totals and discuss whether you feel those totals reflect the true priorities in jaguar conservation.

Make sure to discuss how a conservation action may be critically important in one region even if it is less important in others.

Discuss how actions that received fewer total points are not necessarily less important everywhere jaguars live.

 
Something to Think About...
  • Do you think we'll be able to create enough reserves to protect the jaguar throughout its range and in all of its habitats?
  • If we did create many reserves, would the jaguars be likely to stay inside them?
  • Is there a way to protect the jaguar that would go beyond the boundaries of reserves and national parks?
     


    ↑top


     


    Step #5 Tip 1
    There are no rules for how points get assigned. One team may decide that all actions are important and that they want to divide their points evenly among them, such as 10 points for 10 elements. Another team may decide that two actions are so important that they want all there points to go to just those two steps, 50 points for one, 50 points for another.


    Step #5 Tip 2
    Someone once described consensus as a situation where "no one's completely happy with the result, but everyone can live with it."
    © 2004 Wildlife Conservation Society.